Two recent launches that have enjoyed particular success are the Punch micro-SUV and the Tiago hatchback. It’s easy to see why these vehicles are making a splash. Both are aimed at young, tech-focused buyers looking for practical urban touring without stretching their budget. The Punch and Tiago have compact footprints that are suitable for congested roads.
Also, they look extremely attractive due to their style and abundant features. Tata has designed these models to meet the needs of urban commuters who are technology enthusiasts but need more money. Let’s see how these two rising stars stand up in terms of dimensions, performance, features and other aspects.
punch and tiago
The Punch car and the Tiago have a lot in common – compact dimensions optimized for congested roads, peppy petrol engines, ample features even in base trims and strong build quality with high safety ratings. However, when it comes to performance, there are some significant differences.
The Punch gets a 1.2L naturally aspirated motor, while the Tiago gets the same engine with a factory-fitted CNG kit option. The Punch also offers the same 5-speed AMT as the Tiago. Let’s analyze how these powertrain variations affect driving dynamics, efficiency and pricing.
With the micro-SUV segment on the rise, the Punch has a fierce rival in the form of the Hyundai Xcent. It also has a sturdy design and is packed with features. If you are not looking for an SUV with compact dimensions, then the Tata Altroz car can be your option as it offers impressive performance and handling and features an aggressive exterior design.
Price comparison: which is more affordable?
While both models start at extremely attractive prices, the Tiago beats the punch as the more affordable option. Here are the pricing details:
tata punch price
- Base Pure MT – Rs. 6.63 lakh
- Top Creative AMT – Rs. 11.83 lakh
tata tiago price
- Base XE MT – Rs. 6.01 lakh
- Top XZ+ AMT – Rs. 9.83 lakh
Performance Comparison – Engine, Gearbox and Efficiency
While the dimensions and price are in favor of the Tiago car, the performance performance yields some interesting results. Let’s analyze the engine specs, transmission options and fuel economy of both models:
engine
- Punch – 1.2 liter Revotron Petrol
- Power – 87 PS
- Torque – 115 Nm
- Tiago – 1.2L Revotron Petrol
- Power – 86 PS
- Torque – 113 Nm
Apparently, the petrol motors are identically matched with minor differences in output. However, transmission options vary:
transfer
- Punch – 5-Speed MT/AMT
- Tiago – 5-Speed MT/AMT + CNG
The Tiago counters with an efficient factory-fitted CNG kit, which boosts economy but compromises boot space. Coming to the efficiency figures:
Benefit
- Punch Petrol MT – 18.97 kmpl
- Punch Petrol AMT – 18.82 kmpl
- Tiago Petrol MT – 19.80 kmpl
- Tiago Petrol AMT – 23.84 kmpl
- Tiago CNG – 26.49 km/kg
The Tiago CNG variant offers segment-leading efficiency but lags behind the punchy petrol in overall performance. Both models are identically matched with petrol engines with similar outputs. Enthusiasts will appreciate the dynamics of the Punch, while mileage-conscious buyers can opt for the Tiago CNG.
Features comparison
Both Tata models are equipped with segment-first equipment, but the Punch has regained the lost ground with added features, justifying its positioning as a micro-SUV.
general facilities
- touchscreen infotainment
- digital instrument cluster
- Rear Parking Sensor + Camera
- automatic climate control
Punch Special Features
- projector headlamps
- cruise control
- leather steering wheel
- rear washer and wiper
Similar to the Tiago, the Punch also offers additional safety kit like dual airbags and ABS from the base variant. So, for those looking for more features, the Punch and Tiago share the same underpinnings.
security comparison
As mentioned earlier, Tata has equipped the Punch and Tiago with a standard safety kit including airbags and ABS right from the base variants.
punch safety
- 5-star global NCAP rating
- dual airbags standard
- abs standard
tiago safety
- 4-star global NCAP rating
- dual airbags standard
- abs standard
The Punch reiterates the Tiago’s strengths on the safety front. It has received a 5-star rating in the Global NCAP crash test, while Tiago has received 4 stars. With airbags and ABS as standard, the Punch and Tiago offer similar protection to the occupants.
Which Tata model wins our vote?
For the value-focused average urban car buyer, the Tiago makes a compelling case as an affordable, efficient and well-equipped hatchback. Its compact dimensions make it easy to navigate even on congested roads.
However, the Punch proves to be an excellent package for those looking for something more premium. Its SUV body style and extra ground clearance give it better stance and presence on the road compared to the Tiago. The onboard safety kit and additional features also justify its positioning as a more advanced model. And it still retains the agility, maneuverability and parking convenience of a compact car.
For driving enthusiasts who enjoy acceleration and better performance, the petrol motors of both models are on par. But the Punch looks and feels like the sportier option. Mileage conscious buyers have the Tiago CNG variant as an option.
Disclaimer: This article is a paid publication and does not have any journalistic/editorial involvement with Hindustan Times. Hindustan Times does not endorse/subscribe to the content and/or views of the articles/advertisements expressed here. Hindustan Times will not be responsible and/or liable in any way for all views, opinions, pronouncements, declarations made and/or stated in the article. The affirmation(s), affirmation(s) etc. are stated/illustrated therein.
